NAVIGATION
  • HOME
  • Broker Rebates
    • XM Rebates
    • HFM Rebates
    • XS Rebates
    • Exness Rebates
  • Trading Tools
    • Calculators
      • Lot Size Calculator
      • Margin Calculator
      • Pip Calculator
      • Rebate Calculator
      • Compounding Calculator
      • Profit Calculator
    • Market Tools
      • Currency Strength
      • Market Hours
      • Best Time to Trade
      • Best Pairs to Trade
      • NinjaBull AI Forecast
    • MT4/MT5 Tools
      • LocalTime Indicator
      • NapWela Timer
      • BreakLine Indicator
      • Interactive MA
      • PidPro
      • MT4/MT5 Setup
    • Forex Basics
      • 0.01 Lot in Dollars
      • Pip Value in Dollars
      • XAUUSD Pips
      • XAUUSD Market Hours
      • Margin Call
      • Demo Accounts
      • Trading Journal
  • NinjaBull
    • How NinjaBull Works
    • EA News Filter (API)
  • Broker Guides
    • Lowest Spread Brokers
    • Zero Spread Brokers
    • Best Broker for Gold
    • Forex Trading Apps
    • Swap-Free Brokers
    • High Leverage Brokers
    • Cent Account Brokers
    • Deposit Bonus Brokers
    • XM vs Exness
    • Most Popular Brokers
    • Broker Changes
    • XM
      • Registration
      • Verification
      • Login
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Standard Account
      • Ultra Low Account
      • Cent Account
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Withdrawal
      • Fees and Charges
      • Inactivity Fee
      • Spreads
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Bonus
      • Demo Competition
      • Traders Club
      • Refer a Friend
      • Copy Trading
      • Additional Account
      • Demo Account
      • Internal Transfer
      • Delete Account
      • Partner Code
      • Support
    • HFM
      • Login
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Deposit
      • Withdrawal Time
      • Spreads and Commissions
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Bonus
      • Demo Account
      • Demo Contest
      • Copy Trading
    • XS.com
      • Account Types
      • Spreads and Fees
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage and Margin
    • Exness
      • Review
      • Personal Area Login
      • Web Terminal
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Withdrawal Time
      • Fees and Charges
      • Spreads
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Demo Account
      • Partner Code
      • Change IB Partner
      • Contact Support
  • Free Forex Course
  • Dashboard
Forex FanClub
  • HOME
  • Broker Rebates
    • XM Rebates
    • HFM Rebates
    • XS Rebates
    • Exness Rebates
  • Trading Tools
    • Calculators
      • Lot Size Calculator
      • Margin Calculator
      • Pip Calculator
      • Rebate Calculator
      • Compounding Calculator
      • Profit Calculator
    • Market Tools
      • Currency Strength
      • Market Hours
      • Best Time to Trade
      • Best Pairs to Trade
      • NinjaBull AI Forecast
    • MT4/MT5 Tools
      • LocalTime Indicator
      • NapWela Timer
      • BreakLine Indicator
      • Interactive MA
      • PidPro
      • MT4/MT5 Setup
    • Forex Basics
      • 0.01 Lot in Dollars
      • Pip Value in Dollars
      • XAUUSD Pips
      • XAUUSD Market Hours
      • Margin Call
      • Demo Accounts
      • Trading Journal
  • NinjaBull
    • How NinjaBull Works
    • EA News Filter (API)
  • Broker Guides
    • Lowest Spread Brokers
    • Zero Spread Brokers
    • Best Broker for Gold
    • Forex Trading Apps
    • Swap-Free Brokers
    • High Leverage Brokers
    • Cent Account Brokers
    • Deposit Bonus Brokers
    • XM vs Exness
    • Most Popular Brokers
    • Broker Changes
    • XM
      • Registration
      • Verification
      • Login
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Standard Account
      • Ultra Low Account
      • Cent Account
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Withdrawal
      • Fees and Charges
      • Inactivity Fee
      • Spreads
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Bonus
      • Demo Competition
      • Traders Club
      • Refer a Friend
      • Copy Trading
      • Additional Account
      • Demo Account
      • Internal Transfer
      • Delete Account
      • Partner Code
      • Support
    • HFM
      • Login
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Deposit
      • Withdrawal Time
      • Spreads and Commissions
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Bonus
      • Demo Account
      • Demo Contest
      • Copy Trading
    • XS.com
      • Account Types
      • Spreads and Fees
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage and Margin
    • Exness
      • Review
      • Personal Area Login
      • Web Terminal
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Withdrawal Time
      • Fees and Charges
      • Spreads
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Demo Account
      • Partner Code
      • Change IB Partner
      • Contact Support
  • Free Forex Course
  • Dashboard
Login
Forex FanClub
  • HOME
  • Broker Rebates
    • XM Rebates
    • HFM Rebates
    • XS Rebates
    • Exness Rebates
  • Trading Tools
    • Calculators
      • Lot Size Calculator
      • Margin Calculator
      • Pip Calculator
      • Rebate Calculator
      • Compounding Calculator
      • Profit Calculator
    • Market Tools
      • Currency Strength
      • Market Hours
      • Best Time to Trade
      • Best Pairs to Trade
      • NinjaBull AI Forecast
    • MT4/MT5 Tools
      • LocalTime Indicator
      • NapWela Timer
      • BreakLine Indicator
      • Interactive MA
      • PidPro
      • MT4/MT5 Setup
    • Forex Basics
      • 0.01 Lot in Dollars
      • Pip Value in Dollars
      • XAUUSD Pips
      • XAUUSD Market Hours
      • Margin Call
      • Demo Accounts
      • Trading Journal
  • NinjaBull
    • How NinjaBull Works
    • EA News Filter (API)
  • Broker Guides
    • Lowest Spread Brokers
    • Zero Spread Brokers
    • Best Broker for Gold
    • Forex Trading Apps
    • Swap-Free Brokers
    • High Leverage Brokers
    • Cent Account Brokers
    • Deposit Bonus Brokers
    • XM vs Exness
    • Most Popular Brokers
    • Broker Changes
    • XM
      • Registration
      • Verification
      • Login
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Standard Account
      • Ultra Low Account
      • Cent Account
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Withdrawal
      • Fees and Charges
      • Inactivity Fee
      • Spreads
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Bonus
      • Demo Competition
      • Traders Club
      • Refer a Friend
      • Copy Trading
      • Additional Account
      • Demo Account
      • Internal Transfer
      • Delete Account
      • Partner Code
      • Support
    • HFM
      • Login
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Deposit
      • Withdrawal Time
      • Spreads and Commissions
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Bonus
      • Demo Account
      • Demo Contest
      • Copy Trading
    • XS.com
      • Account Types
      • Spreads and Fees
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage and Margin
    • Exness
      • Review
      • Personal Area Login
      • Web Terminal
      • App
      • Account Types
      • Minimum Deposit
      • Withdrawal Time
      • Fees and Charges
      • Spreads
      • Swap Rates
      • Leverage
      • Margin Calculator
      • Demo Account
      • Partner Code
      • Change IB Partner
      • Contact Support
  • Free Forex Course
  • Dashboard
  1. Home
  2. Free Forex Trading Tools: Calculators and MT4/MT5 Indicators
  3. How to Keep a Trading Journal: What to Write, When, and How to Review It

How to Keep a Trading Journal: What to Write, When, and How to Review It

Forex FanClub

You keep a trading journal to become stronger. You admit your weaknesses, and you become stronger. That is why a trader is not just a title.

Updated on 17 November 2026

Most traders get this wrong. Trading does not make you stronger overnight. But a trader who admits their weaknesses and works hard to become stronger will, naturally, become stronger. This page explains the trading journal, a guide to becoming stronger as a trader and as a person.

If you do not use a forex rebate yet, there is room to rethink your trading conditions before you even start a journal. The button below opens the rebate programme that we recommend.

Compare Forex Rebates

Contents

  1. Why Should You Keep a Trading Journal?
  2. What Changes When You Keep a Trading Journal?
  3. What Should You Write in a Trading Journal?
  4. What Should You Write Before You Enter a Trade?
  5. What Should You Write After You Close a Trade?
  6. What Does a Completed Journal Entry Look Like?
  7. How Do You Add Chart Screenshots Quickly?
  8. How Do You Review Your Trading Journal Each Week?
  9. How Do You Set a Goal for Next Week?
  10. What Are the Rules for Your First 30 Days?
  11. Should You Keep Your Journal in Excel, Notion or an App?
  12. Does a Trading Journal Really Work?
  13. Questions About Keeping a Trading Journal
  14. Which Page Do You Need Next?

Why Should You Keep a Trading Journal?

You keep a trading journal to see yourself as you really are as a trader, because that is where getting stronger starts. A journal also builds discipline, so you can keep growing as a trader.

Everyone sees themselves as a better trader than they are. We tell ourselves “the market was against me” or “next time I will close the trade at my stop-loss”.

Excuses like these are small lies that we tell ourselves. Memory helps the lies, because memory changes to protect us.

A trading journal does not accept the lies. What you thought before the trade, where you hesitated and why you broke your own rule stay on the page exactly as you wrote them.

When you read your journal again, you see the trader you really are, not the trader you thought you were. Seeing the real trader is the starting point.

Every trader is weak at first. Being weak is normal, and there is no shame in being weak. You become stronger because you work on your weaknesses, and you can only work on a weakness after you admit it.

What Changes When You Keep a Trading Journal?

When you keep a trading journal, you can see your own progress. You find your mistakes and excuses in your past trades, you check why they happened, and you fix them one at a time. If you put last month’s journal next to this month’s journal, you can see exactly what changed.

As you keep writing your trading journal, weaknesses like these appear:

  • You hold a losing trade past your planned stop-loss.
  • You close a winning trade before your target.
  • Every chart looks like a chance to trade.
  • You never test whether your method really works.
  • You blame the market instead of your own mistakes.
  • A big loss or a lucky win from the past still controls you.

Every weakness leaves a clear mark in your journal, so you can find each weakness, count it and fix it.

What matters is that you admit your weaknesses and become stronger. A trading journal is the most reliable tool for becoming stronger.

Have you ever seen a famous baseball player on TV telling children that their dreams will come true? The player is not saying it just to be kind. The player means it. Effort is the only thing in this world that never betrays you. So if you keep making the effort, your dream will come true.

What Should You Write in a Trading Journal?

You can write anything you like in a trading journal. Write with all your passion, as fast as your hand can move. If you were bullied in the past, write about that too. Picture the face of the person you can never forgive, and type.

There is no correct way to keep a trading journal. But some traders want a model to start from, so this page shows one way to write a journal.

The model starts from one idea. Your MT5 history already keeps your profit or loss, win rate and number of trades, so you do not need to copy the numbers. The model uses the journal for what exists only in your head: what you thought before the trade, how you felt, and whether you kept your rules.

MT5 history keepsYour journal keeps
Symbol, lot size, pricesYour reason, in one sentence
Profit, commission, swapYour stop-loss and target
Win rate, number of tradesYour feelings, before and after
Trade timesThe rules you kept or broke
No chartsTwo chart screenshots

What Should You Write Before You Enter a Trade?

In this model, you write five things before you place the order. Writing first helps you notice the trades that you are about to open on impulse.

  • Setup
    You give your type of trade a name, such as “buy after a pullback” or “sell at the top of a range”. A few setups of your own are enough.
  • Reason
    One sentence is enough. If you cannot find a reason, the journal shows the missing reason too.
  • Stop-loss and target
    You write both as prices. The distance from your entry to your stop-loss is your risk, called 1R. So a target twice as far away is a 2R target.
  • Market conditions
    For example, you write the direction on the higher timeframe and any important economic news in the next few hours.
  • Feeling
    You write your feeling honestly, for example calm, in a hurry, wanting to win back a loss, or tired.

If you have your own trading rules, you can tick the rules on the same list each time. If you enter a trade while a rule is not ticked, you write the broken rule down honestly as well.

What Should You Write After You Close a Trade?

In this model, you write how many R you won or lost and whether you kept your rules, on the day you close the trade. If you wait longer, your memory changes the story in your favour.

  • Result
    You write how many R you won or lost, not the amount of money. For example, a profit of half your stop-loss distance is +0.5R. With R, you can compare trades of any lot size.
  • Rules
    For each rule that you ticked before the trade, you write whether you kept the rule until the close.
  • Type of mistake
    If you give each type of mistake the same name every time, such as “late stop-loss” or “early profit”, you can count your mistakes later.
  • Feeling after the trade
    You write how you felt, for example relieved, angry, or wanting to win back the loss.
  • Lesson
    One lesson is enough.
  • Grade from A to D
    You grade how well you followed your own process, not the profit. A losing trade that followed your process is an A. A winning trade that broke your rules is a D.

You can drop any item that does not help you, and you can add your own items. The lot size calculator turns your stop-loss distance into a lot size, so that 1R is the same amount of money on every trade.

What Does a Completed Journal Entry Look Like?

A completed journal entry has a before part, written before the order, and an after part, written on the day of the close. The entry here is a made-up example of one EURUSD trade. The rules in the example are one trader’s own rules, and your rules will be different.

Before the order

Setup
Buy after a pullback
Reason
On the 4-hour chart the trend is up, and on the 1-hour chart the price fell back to the last high and stopped there.
Stop-loss and target
Entry 1.0850, stop-loss 1.0830, target 1.0890. The target is 2.0R.
Market conditions
The 4-hour trend is up. The US jobs report comes out in 3 hours.
Feeling
Calm
Rules
Trade with the higher timeframe ✓
Close 30 minutes before big news ✓
No more than 3 trades a day ✓
Screenshot
The 1-hour chart at the entry

After the trade closes

Result
Closed at 1.0862, +0.6R
Rules
Hold until the target ✗ (closed early)
Type of mistake
Early profit
Feeling
Afraid of losing the open profit
Lesson
When a trade is in profit, I want to close it at once.
Your grade
C
Screenshot
The 1-hour chart at the close

One entry like the example is only a record. When you count how many times “early profit” happened in a month, the weakness becomes a number.

How Do You Add Chart Screenshots Quickly?

Two screenshots for each trade are enough: one when you enter and one when you close. If you want a higher timeframe as well, you add one screenshot when you enter. More screenshots make the journal harder to keep up.

  • Windows
    You press `Win + Shift + S`, select the chart in MT5, and paste the chart into your journal with `Ctrl + V`. You do not need to save a file and find the file again.
  • MT5
    You right-click on the chart and choose Save as Picture. You put the date and the instrument in the file name, so that you can find the file later.
  • PidPro
    Our free PidPro tool for MT4 and MT5 adds a Screenshot button to your chart. One click saves the chart as a PNG file, without the PidPro panel, and the file name has the date, the time and the symbol.
  • TradingView
    You click the camera icon to take a snapshot, copy the link and paste the link into your journal. You can open the chart again from the link without saving a file.

How Do You Review Your Trading Journal Each Week?

A good rhythm is to review your trading journal once a week, on a fixed day, for about 30 minutes. Your daily entries collect the facts. You see your weaknesses only when you review the entries.

In the model, you look at three numbers:

  • The total result in R of the trades where you broke a rule
  • The type of mistake that happened most often
  • The result of each setup

For example, you made 12 trades in a week. The 8 trades where you kept your rules made +3.1R, and the 4 trades where you broke a rule lost 5.2R.

So the 4 trades where you broke a rule made the losing week, not the market. When you see the loss as a number, you have no excuse left.

After the review, you write three things:

  • What you did well
  • What you need to fix
  • One goal for next week

Once a month, you review four weeks together. You check whether last month’s goal is fixed and whether a new weakness has appeared.

How Do You Set a Goal for Next Week?

You set next week’s goal as an action, not as a profit, because the market moves your profit but you decide your actions. You set the goal so that at the next review you can count whether you did the action.

  • Bad goal
    “Be more patient” or “use my stop-loss properly”. Neither goal gives you a number to check.
  • Good goal
    “Hold no trade past my planned stop-loss this week” or “write the reason before every order, and open no trade without the reason this week”.

Set one goal only. Fix one weakness, and then move to the next weakness. If you try to fix everything at once, nothing gets fixed.

What Are the Rules for Your First 30 Days?

For your first 30 days, you keep the five rules with no exceptions. A journal only works if you keep writing the journal, and the most common reason people stop is the thought “just this once, it does not matter”.

  1. Write down every trade. This includes your winning trades and your small trades.
  2. Write the after part on the day you close the trade.
  3. Write the before part before you place the order. If you write it after the order, mark the trade.
  4. Do not move your weekly review day.
  5. On a day when you could not write, write why.

Print a list of the 30 days and tick each day that you kept the rules. After 30 ticks, you have an honest record of 30 days, and the record shows who you really are as a trader.

Should You Keep Your Journal in Excel, Notion or an App?

To start, a spreadsheet in Excel or Google Sheets is enough, because what matters is that you keep writing, not the tool. Your profit and win rate stay in the MT5 history.

  • Excel or Google Sheets
    Both are free to start, and Google Sheets works on a computer and a phone. Counting and sorting are easy, so a spreadsheet suits the weekly review.
  • Notion
    Notion keeps screenshots and text together well, but counting needs some set-up.
  • A paid journal app
    An app gives you totals and charts from the start. You can think about an app after the habit is in place.

If you use the model, the format is one row for each trade and one column for each item on this page: date, instrument, setup, reason, stop-loss, target, market conditions, feeling before, rules kept, result (R), type of mistake, feeling after, lesson, grade and the two screenshots. With these columns, you have your own trading journal template.

Does a Trading Journal Really Work?

It is understandable to doubt whether a trading journal really works. Most traders in the world probably feel the same way, and that doubt is why most traders never become stronger.

Effort never betrays you. If you do the work, you can get it done. If you do not do the work, nothing gets done. Effort that you make with your teeth clenched has real value. That is why a trader is not just a title.

Questions About Keeping a Trading Journal

How long should one journal entry take?

One journal entry takes about 1 minute before the trade and 3 minutes after the close. If writing takes longer, you write fewer items.

Should you write down demo trades too?

Yes. If you cannot keep your rules on a demo account, keeping the rules is even harder with real money. So you build the journal habit on a demo account first.

Should you write down winning trades too?

Yes. A winning trade that broke your rules teaches you a bad habit, and that habit leads to a bigger loss later. Without a record, you cannot see the bad habits inside your winning trades.

What if you forget to write an entry?

You open the MT5 history, write what you remember, and mark the entry as written later. Then you write one line about why you forgot the entry.

Which Page Do You Need Next?

The lot size calculator gives you the lot size for your stop-loss, so that 1R is the same amount of money on every trade. The other tools work out a trade before you open the trade.

Lot size calculatorThe lot size that makes 1R the same amount on every trade› Profit calculatorYour profit or loss after costs, before you open the trade› Pip calculatorThe value of 1 pip for your lot size› All free forex toolsCalculators and MT4/MT5 indicators› Free forex courseFrom how money grows to daily practice, in six stages›
Keep your rebate history in one place

Once your rebate account is open, link it to Forex FanClub. The member area lists every rebate payment day by day, across every broker you use. Registration is free and takes an email address.

Join Forex FanClub (opens in a new tab)
Forex FanClub

Produced and operated by Forex FanClub
Person responsible: Hiroki Sakaida, founder of Forex FanClub

Hiroki Sakaida decides what our content and services cover and which features they offer. He also checks content and functionality and decides on revisions and publication. Our Content and Service Policy explains how we produce and check our content and services, including our use of AI.

About the company | Report a correction or issue

Risk warning: Forex and CFD trading involve leverage, and you could lose all the money you invest. This article provides information, not investment advice. The amounts shown are calculated from the collected data and do not guarantee the amounts that will apply to your own trades, or any future profit.
Affiliate disclosure: The broker pages linked from this page contain referral links. Forex FanClub receives referral commission based on registrations and trading through those links.

Contents
×
  • Why Should You Keep a Trading Journal?
  • What Changes When You Keep a Trading Journal?
  • What Should You Write in a Trading Journal?
  • What Should You Write Before You Enter a Trade?
  • What Should You Write After You Close a Trade?
  • What Does a Completed Journal Entry Look Like?
  • How Do You Add Chart Screenshots Quickly?
  • How Do You Review Your Trading Journal Each Week?
  • How Do You Set a Goal for Next Week?
  • What Are the Rules for Your First 30 Days?
  • Should You Keep Your Journal in Excel, Notion or an App?
  • Does a Trading Journal Really Work?
  • Questions About Keeping a Trading Journal
  • Which Page Do You Need Next?